Comments on: What is Government? pt. 2 http://micahtillman.com/2008/06/19/what-is-government-pt-2/ Of all the Micah Tillmans in the world -- and there are at least three -- ... I am this one. Wed, 28 Jul 2010 01:18:40 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.0.1 By: Micah Tillman http://micahtillman.com/2008/06/19/what-is-government-pt-2/comment-page-1/#comment-2883 Micah Tillman Mon, 23 Jun 2008 23:12:06 +0000 http://micahtillman.com/?p=459#comment-2883 It's called "exploring the idea," Jeff, not "creating more questions than answering the old ones," and it has a long and noble intellectual tradition. *grin* I think you're right that most people think about this issue in these terms, if they think about it at all. But I don't care for the moment what an ideal (Plato) or excellent (Aristotle) government would be, or what government should do, etc. I want to know what makes both the best and worst governments (both George Washington's and George W's, for instance) recognizable as a government. Another way of putting it: what is it about the things we call "governments" that makes it legitimate to call them "governments" even though some of the are juntas, others are representative republics, others are dictatorships, others are communist, others are monarchies, etc. It’s called “exploring the idea,” Jeff, not “creating more questions than answering the old ones,” and it has a long and noble intellectual tradition. *grin*

I think you’re right that most people think about this issue in these terms, if they think about it at all.

But I don’t care for the moment what an ideal (Plato) or excellent (Aristotle) government would be, or what government should do, etc. I want to know what makes both the best and worst governments (both George Washington’s and George W’s, for instance) recognizable as a government.

Another way of putting it: what is it about the things we call “governments” that makes it legitimate to call them “governments” even though some of the are juntas, others are representative republics, others are dictatorships, others are communist, others are monarchies, etc.

]]> By: jeffsdeepthoughts http://micahtillman.com/2008/06/19/what-is-government-pt-2/comment-page-1/#comment-2871 jeffsdeepthoughts Mon, 23 Jun 2008 13:21:02 +0000 http://micahtillman.com/?p=459#comment-2871 I wonder if there are actually two questions floating around in the question "Do you know what government is?" The first "Do you know what government should be?" ( Related questions: What's the platonic form of government; what was it intended to be; how best would a theoretical government work) The second is "Do you know what the government actually is right now? Presuming their is a gulf between question 1 and question 2, working on the assumption that it has drifted/mutated/been perverted from what it should be doing, it seems like an ideal politician would have a plan for getting us from where we are to where we should/ want to be. Isn't it always easier to create more questions than answer the old ones? ;) I wonder if there are actually two questions floating around in the question “Do you know what government is?”
The first “Do you know what government should be?” ( Related questions: What’s the platonic form of government; what was it intended to be; how best would a theoretical government work)
The second is “Do you know what the government actually is right now?
Presuming their is a gulf between question 1 and question 2, working on the assumption that it has drifted/mutated/been perverted from what it should be doing, it seems like an ideal politician would have a plan for getting us from where we are to where we should/ want to be.
Isn’t it always easier to create more questions than answer the old ones?
;)

]]>